Welcome, Guest. Please Login 3dfx Archive
 
  HomeHelpSearchLogin  
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP (Read 623 times)
DenisF
Senior Member
****
Offline


So fluffy it hurts

Posts: 409
Israel
Gender: male
First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
05.02.04 at 12:35:33
 
Well i just got my voodoo4500 this morning, put it in the pc, and started benchmarking..


To my surprise, it was /actually slower/ than my voodoo3...
3dmark2001 Voodoo3 benchmark (1024*768*16bit); 1422 points
3dmark2001 Voodoo4 benchmark (1024*768*16bit*DXTC); 1356 points

The voodoo3 is clocked at 180mhz (made by STB, Siemens ram), and the voodoo4 clocked at 185mhz (hundai ram).

The same appeared in many of my games; Tactical Ops (UT based), DeusEx (also UT based), and Steam (DoD/HalfLife).

Is there something i'm doing wrong here? Sad


EDIT
Uh yes system specs;
Voodoo3: AmigaSport3 drivers, WinXPsp1a, DX9.0b
Voodoo4: AmigaMerlin3 drivers, WinXPsp1a, DX9.0b

Also iv'e noticed that Windows Plus! screen savers (robot circus and sand pendulum) work on the default voodoo4 driver that came with windows, but crash on amigamerlin3 drivers... Sad
Back to top
« Last Edit: 05.02.04 at 12:38:14 by DenisF »  

[
Powered By:
]
[
Abit NF7-S Rev2.0
] [
AMD Athlon-XP Mobile 2600+@200x12 1.7v
]&&[
GeiL Golden Dragon PC3200 512mB Dual Channel Kit
] [
ATi Radeon 9700 PRO 128mB
]
&&...
138674373 denisfak  
IP Logged
 
Micha
Senior Member
****
Offline


Got milk?

Posts: 317
Gender: male
Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #1 - 05.02.04 at 14:04:40
 
er..as i know the voodoo4 is clocked at 166mhz and voodoo3 at 143/166/183 (concerning the version). if you own a voodoo3 3500 you won't get a speed-up when updating to a voodoo4, except 32bit support and the other stuff..from which vendor(s) are your cards from? i can remember there were voodoo3s & 4s from powercolor..or have you just o/c? then try again with normal clockrates, even if 3dmark isn't the best way to bench out a voodoo...try with standalone ut (--> press       during gameplay, type stat fps & press enter)
Back to top
« Last Edit: 05.02.04 at 14:09:43 by Micha »  

AMD Athlon XP Thorton 2400+/2GHz (256KB L2, FSB DDR266MHz) @ Barton 2800+/2.083GHz (512KB L2, FSB DDR333MHz), HIS Radeon 9800Pro, Kingston 768MB PC2700 DDR-RAM (CL 2-3-3-7), Asus A7V8X-X, Creative Soundblaster Audigy 2 ZS, Seagate 160GB 7200rpm ATA100 HDD, be quiet! 400Watt PSU, Windows XP Pro MCE05
WWW  
IP Logged
 
FalconFly
YaBB Administrator
*****
Offline


3dfx Archivist

Posts: 2453
5335N 00745E
Gender: male
Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #2 - 05.02.04 at 15:26:24
 
Yep, run it on Games that make use of the 32MB RAM, large Textures, or DXTC/S3TC to see what makes the Voodoo4 the superior Card Smiley

(or, for that matter, enable FSAA Grin )

On many old Games, people reported the Voodoo4 was identical to slightly slower than a Voodoo3 3000.

Only on Games (today, that should be about all Games) that go beyond what a Voodoo3 can offer, you will see the significant advantages Smiley
Back to top
« Last Edit: 05.02.04 at 15:26:42 by FalconFly »  
WWW  
IP Logged
 
nudgegoonies
Full Member
***
Offline


C64

Posts: 182
Germany
Gender: male
Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #3 - 05.02.04 at 18:11:36
 
I had a similar problem when upgrading from voodoo˛ 12mb 90mhz to voodooł 16mb 166mhz. The only problem is that those games that make use of the more texure-ram/higher resolutions need more cpu power than i have. As Falconfly said in the corresponding thread "the cpu must be fast enough to feed the 3dboard"!

Regards,
Andreas
Back to top
 

Board: Asus CUSL-2-C (Chipset: Intel i815), CPU: Intel PIII 933, RAM: 2 Infineon 128MB (1 PC133-333, 1 PC133-222) and 1 Infineon 256MB (PC 333-333) SD-RAM, Video: 3dfx Voodoo 3 3000 AGP, TV: LifeView FlyKit (Chipset: BT848, Tuner: No), Sound: Creative Labs Soundblaster PCI 512, NET: 3COM Etherlink XL Combo OS: Windows 98SE with SESP21D, Video Driver: 1.07.00 with GLIDE and OGL from 1.07.00b
 
IP Logged
 
janskjaer
Ex Member


Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #4 - 05.02.04 at 21:33:36
 
Still waiting for my Voodoo4 arrives! Will give it a test once it appears, and let you know on the tests I make! Roll Eyes
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
janskjaer
Ex Member


Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #5 - 09.03.04 at 19:38:03
 
Sorry, my Voodoo4 is a PCI version.

I ran it in my girlfriend's machine (AMD XP 2200+, 512 Mb 2100 RAM, MSI AGP8x Mobo KT400, Radeon 9000 Pro2) with GTA3, and it ran pretty well compared to the Radeon 9000.   Cheesy It was about 10fps down on the Radeon in highly complex areas, but still playable at the same resolution of 1024x768, with full distance detail drawing and trails.  Used with AmigaMerlin 3.0 drivers on WinXP.
Then I tried my Voodoo5 5500 PCI, hoping to better that! Boy was I wrong!  Shocked
The game was unplayble! It ran at 2fps! Same settings, better card, worst performance!  How? Why? Undecided
Again, used the AmigaMerlin 3.0 drivers on WinXP.  I even turned the distance detail drawing down to quite near, and still no difference, even in simple texture areas of the game.  Why is this?  ???
The setting that always stayed ON throughout all 3 tests was the Frame Limiter in GTA3, but why would that make the V5 perform different to the V4 and Radeon?
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
amp_man
Ex Member


Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #6 - 11.03.04 at 00:59:41
 
Sounds like your V5 has bit the dust  Cry Or it's madly overheating, and slowing way down to try and compensate, or simply because of problems from overheating. Is it OCed? It also might be an issue with the SLI, perhaps changing the FSAA to Single-Chip will make it run (I've heard of single-chip burnouts, where it only affects D3D, not OGL or Glide, but this was artifacts, not slow).
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
VDX
Ex Member


Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #7 - 11.03.04 at 22:01:05
 
Hey, i noticed there is a sweet spot when overcloacking my voodoo's, i get an incress to a certain point in the 2001se test but after a point it starts to slow down even though it runs the test just fine, maybe you have hit that point, id try it set to default and work your way up till you see a decress and then back off a bit from there, to close to the edge for to long just burns these cards out Cry  plus frame rates dont really jump up like you think they would with a 20 to 30 bump up, ive run my v5500 at 200 and it wasnt much better than at 183 where i keep it for gamming Tongue
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
janskjaer
Ex Member


Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #8 - 12.03.04 at 08:51:17
 
I'm not sure if it's OC'ed or not.  I only bought it recently off the original owner.  I ran some of the Glide/3dfx tests on it (supplied on this site by FalconFly) and they seemed to work fine, but that was in my machine.  I didn't get enough time to thoroughly test it on my girlfriends machine, just run it with GTA3.

I will put it back in my machine and run 3DMark2001 on it, and see how it performs.

How can I tell if this card is overclocked?  Either physically or software based?
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Andrew Boiu
Senior Member
****
Offline


LDE-BDreams

Posts: 267
LDE-BDreams
Gender: male
Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #9 - 12.03.04 at 09:23:14
 
The most visible effects of overclocking are slowly drops in performance (when you have done a fresh start of the system and imediately started the game and you have 20fps average, as oposed to after 30 minutes of playing in the same area, when you get to 11fps), and sudden "glitches".

Also a random lockup (after 5 minutes sometimes, after 12 minutes at other time, or 2 minutes at other times), no matter what settings you have, and no matter what 3D scene is displayed, MIGHT suggest an overheating problem.

The first thing to keep on mind is that most of the time the card can produce quite a lot of heating. You need a reasonable heatsink, but most of the time the lack of a fan fails to provide a proper cooling. The airflow inside the case is also very important. It is thus recommended to arrange the cables inside the case so that around the CPU and the video card you have plenty of space for air to travel.
Back to top
 
WWW  
IP Logged
 
janskjaer
Ex Member


Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #10 - 12.03.04 at 09:33:17
 
Both machines are well ventilated with wires tied and bracketed along the case walls to allow free air flow. Two large fans have also been installed by me in my machine. One large fan intakes are from the front and the one at the back of the case blows out the air as it gets hot, travelling through the system.

I'll test everything and see what I come up with.

Thanks guys.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Andrew Boiu
Senior Member
****
Offline


LDE-BDreams

Posts: 267
LDE-BDreams
Gender: male
Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #11 - 12.03.04 at 10:14:12
 
And the videocard heatsink and fan is...?
Back to top
« Last Edit: 12.03.04 at 10:14:23 by Andrew Boiu »  
WWW  
IP Logged
 
amp_man
Ex Member


Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #12 - 12.03.04 at 21:18:07
 
Quote:
The most visible effects of overclocking are slowly drops in performance


lol, I'm fairly sure you mean overheating? Overclocking on the voodoos is normally done via software, so you would know if it was oveclocked or not. Just to be sure, in the 3dfx tools, there could be an option somewhere (that huge list, I think) to set the clock speed, that should either not be set, or set at 166/167 (because the actual speed is 166 2/3, I don't know where it would round to)
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Andrew Boiu
Senior Member
****
Offline


LDE-BDreams

Posts: 267
LDE-BDreams
Gender: male
Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #13 - 15.03.04 at 07:12:23
 
However, I think that the Banshee example might be worth a look. The Banshee, even if it is clocked at 90Mhz (not overclocked or forced in speed) it still runs pretty hot, even with the heatsink and fan combination. If the fan fails, then the card is freezing or performance drops a lot.

The point is that some videocards can heat quite a lot because of their design. And some of them (The Banshee) can give serious problems even when the fan is working, but not at full speed. There will be interesting to find out if the fan/heatsink combination is working perfectly on the V4 card on this thread.
Back to top
 
WWW  
IP Logged
 
DenisF
Senior Member
****
Offline


So fluffy it hurts

Posts: 409
Israel
Gender: male
Re: First impression of my Voodoo4 4500AGP
Reply #14 - 15.03.04 at 09:24:27
 
If you're talking about my v4, then yeah it's working like a charm.
i got it running at 210mhz perfectly stable with stock cooling, and nothing on the card goes beyond 30c even after running games for a couple of hours Smiley
Back to top
 

[
Powered By:
]
[
Abit NF7-S Rev2.0
] [
AMD Athlon-XP Mobile 2600+@200x12 1.7v
]&&[
GeiL Golden Dragon PC3200 512mB Dual Channel Kit
] [
ATi Radeon 9700 PRO 128mB
]
&&...
138674373 denisfak  
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print